There's a loaded question. I work on hundreds of skins from tanneries all over the United States, on a yearly basis and have for the past 18 years. The problem with the consistency of shaving lies in the fact that shavers may come and go, at a facility, and the trial period of breaking in a new shaver may be a bit shaky for while, until they get their system down pat. Keeping a good employee is a problem in all areas of the taxidermy business, including tanneries.
I think the majority of all tanneries are consistant, you just need to be aware of the changing variables. I would not give up on a tannery you have had great success with just because you get one bad batch, but if they are consistant with a batch or two of poor quality, it's time to move on.With the amount of shaving a new shaver does on a daily basis, it shouldn't take long to perfect the skill.
I have seen incredible work from many tanneries and some occasional poor work from the same tanneries over the past 18 years.
Some of my all time favorites for skins for rugmaking, where I get great stretch and have a good evenly shaved ,clean haired, well neutralized and oiled skins are YOST, Carolina, and the Wildlife Gallery. Don't get me wrong ,there are many great tanneries out there, but I see these the most for rugmaking . From time to time even my favorites fall short of their usual quality. When you work with the volume tanneries do, you are going to have a mishap from time to time.
Just my opinion!
