Hi Mike,
I am currently working on a restoration on a Northern, and cut all the original fins off and went to artificial.
They were in terrible shape and would have been very long process to make them look decent.

>I also do quite a few Trout and use a fair amount of artificial replacements on them as well.
>Stream Trout tend to spend most of their time in the rocks and the Pectoral and pelvic fins get pretty beat up and sometimes it's better to start over.

>Trout club fish spend most of their youth in captivity and the tanks are often made of or lined with concrete and or rock, I have done several of these fish that had nothing left but nubs for pelvic fins from laying on the bottom in the current.
All that being said, I stay with nature whenever I can...... You just can't beat her at her own game......

Have a great day,
Bud
By the way check out my post on the restoration of the 60 year old Northern, and let me know if you have anything in mind that may be of help.
Thanks